Best Halloween Milkshake Flavors: Pumpkin Spice, Candy Corn & More

A milkshake might not be the first thing people think of for Halloween, but a thick, cold milkshake is exactly the kind of treat that pairs well with a chilly October night in Chicago. At Crepe Nation Express, our milkshake menu already includes several flavors that fit the fall season perfectly, and we have put together a guide to the best combinations for anyone planning a Halloween outing, a party, or just a solo treat run.

1. Cinnamon Milkshake: The Closest Thing to Pumpkin Spice

   

   
   

Our Cinnamon milkshake captures the warm, spiced flavor people associate with pumpkin spice season. It is a simple order, but it delivers the cozy, autumnal flavor that so many people crave once the weather turns in Chicago.

2. Caramel Milkshake: Caramel Apple, Without the Apple

Caramel is one of the defining flavors of fall, largely thanks to caramel apples at every October festival and farmers market. Our Caramel milkshake brings that same flavor into a cold, blended format, and it pairs particularly well with our Apple Caramel crepe if you want a full caramel-apple experience.

3. Oreo Milkshake: A Black-and-White Halloween Classic

Few flavors say Halloween quite like Oreo, and our Oreo milkshake leans into the classic black-and-white cookie flavor that shows up everywhere from candy displays to costume color schemes this time of year.

4. Peanut Butter Milkshake: Rich, Warm, and Filling

For anyone who wants something heartier for a cold October evening, our Peanut Butter milkshake is dense, rich, and satisfying enough to serve as a full dessert on its own.

5. Chocolate and Coffee: A Two-Flavor Halloween Combo

Ask for our Chocolate and Coffee milkshakes side by side for a party, and you have an instant black-and-brown Halloween color scheme that requires no special seasonal ingredients at all. Both flavors are already on our standard menu, which makes this an easy option for group orders.

6. Build a Halloween Milkshake Flight

If you are hosting a Halloween gathering or bringing friends to our Chicago location, consider ordering a flight of smaller milkshakes across a few flavors: Cinnamon, Caramel, Oreo, and Chocolate cover most of the flavor notes people associate with the holiday, from spice to classic black-and-white to rich cocoa.

7. Order Your Halloween Milkshake in Chicago

Every flavor mentioned here is available now on the Crepe Nation Express drinks menu, priced at 7.00 each. Stop into our Chicago location this Halloween season, or place an order ahead of your next gathering. We will share any limited-time seasonal milkshake specials on our social channels as October continues.